Rat and Mouse
Wed
24
May
Second homes arse-kicking contest: Telegraph v Guardian

The Guardian and George Monbiot:

Second-home owners are among the most selfish people in Britain. Every purchase of a second house deprives someone else of a first one. The only answer is to tax them prohibitively. I would like to see the ownership of second homes become prohibitively expensive, wherever they might be.

The Telegraph editorial:

If the Government adopts these proposals, it will be in order further to punish middle-class voters and to benefit from a grievance culture stoked by envy. Second home owners already pay 90 per cent council tax for services they infrequently use, in addition to the money they spend on local shops and services.

Remember, you can now comment at the Rat and Mouse. You views are always welcome.

Comments

I have worked for over 20 years, often til 11pm each night and I've saved like mad. I haven't spent the money on planet destroying aeroplanes to go on exotic holidays. I haven't spent it on drugs or excessive amounts of booze and I haven't spent it on clothes and hairdos or cosmetic treatments. I have - like everyone else - done what I chose with it which is to buy a second home. It's not even a holiday home but in rough part of London and the reason is it happens to be near where my husband works, so that as well as paying excessive taxes on his income, he can have a life in the evenings instead of sitting on trains and buses for another 3 hours just to get home to go to bed and get up again for it to all start again. We also like doing places up but it's hardly an industry - more a ten year plan to help offset our miserable private pensions that were missold to us all those years ago.

The fact is that someone was more than happy to sell us their home for top whack - just as all the homeowners in Cornwall and Devon are happy to get the highest prices for their's. I don't see much charity with them offering knockdown prices to their neighbour's children! This is an easy target and indeed, the politics of envy. It isn't thought through and if we give up our jobs, sell our two homes and go live in one in the country, retiring and living on the income (as we could!) then that's two lots of 40% tax not going to the government, and all the money we put into local shops, tradesmen, local rates gone too. There must be such a small percentage of people lucky enough to be in the position to have more than one home, but we're not all fat lazy millionaires doing it to spite everyone else. Honest!

Posted by sarah at May 25, 2006 10:33 AM

Comments

Sarah, I don't think many people have a problem with "second" homes that are frequently used i.e. lived in every week. The problem is those people who are buying holiday homes to visit for a few weekends or weeks in a year - that is what is selfish.

Posted by James Smith at May 25, 2006 10:52 AM

Comments

I tend to agree.

"The posh people buying second homes in Cornwall" debate is a diversion tactic to distract voters from the real issues around housing.

There is a shortage of proper family housing "units" and the answer is not to build a million studio flats for low income people and Key workers in the East End. Prescot can't even sell this type of housing as it's not what people want.

It's also not just the very poor who can't afford housing, so do we build more homes for a full range of incomes? And how do you deal with NIMBYs?

It's easier to find a group of people to blame rather than fix the problem.

Just like we can all blame 4x4 drivers for car pollution

Posted by Marcus at May 25, 2006 11:55 AM


Please feel free to comment on this entry







 


POSTCODES
THANKS TO
ENTRIES BY MONTH
ABOUT
UK PROPERTY RESOURCES
US / INTERNATIONAL PROPERTY BLOGS
LONDON BLOGS
CREDITS
Publisher Editor Technical and Design Hosting Software